Underwriting is the work of deciding what a property is worth to us, and whether we should own it at the price on offer. A spreadsheet is the visible part, but the spreadsheet only organizes judgments about income, costs, capital, debt and time. This chapter explains the concepts behind those judgments, with worked numbers labeled as illustrative arithmetic, and describes how we apply them.
Our published target is 15%+ net IRR with a 1.8x+ equity multiple, and we underwrite to reach it without heroic assumptions. The figures are targets for underwriting, not promises or reported results.
Five questions behind every model
- What does the property earn today, really? Not the seller’s pro forma, but income and expenses as they actually occurred, adjusted for one-time items and for costs that will change on a sale, such as property taxes. See reading a T-12 and rent roll.
- What will it earn after the work we plan? Each lever (renovation premiums, mark-to-market, expense savings) is tested against evidence from comparable properties. See NOI and cap rates.
- What are we paying, all in, and how does that compare with building new? See yield on cost, basis and replacement cost.
- How much debt, if any, can the property carry safely? See debt sizing: DSCR, debt yield and LTV.
- What does the equity earn, and over what period? See IRR versus equity multiple.
Habits we follow
Basis first
We focus on what we pay relative to replacement cost and to what comparable buildings trade for, because a sound basis protects capital when everything else goes wrong. A good business plan on a bad basis is a bad investment.
Conservative leverage
We are never forced to refinance into a difficult market. Leverage, where we use it, is sized so that a downturn is an inconvenience rather than an existential event. We test the plan with no debt at all, then add debt only where it makes a good unlevered investment better without making it fragile.
Exit-agnostic
Every acquisition must make sense as a long-term hold. A sale is an option we can choose, not an outcome we depend on. We still model a sale, with an exit cap rate at or above the going-in rate, because a value must be measurable to be managed. But if the only way an investment works is a sale at a lower cap rate than we paid, we pass.
Evidence over pro forma
We underwrite rent premiums from renovated comparables we can see, not from a broker’s projection. We underwrite expenses from the property’s own history and from peers we know, adjusted for what a sale will change.
No heroic growth
Rent growth assumptions are anchored to the submarket’s long-term history, not its best years. The business plan should produce its return from the work we do, not from the market.
A simple model, step by step
Illustrative numbers only. A 200-unit community is offered at $36M ($180,000 per unit).
| Line | Amount |
|---|---|
| In-place NOI (adjusted for post-sale taxes and insurance) | $2.0M |
| Going-in cap rate ($2.0M ÷ $36M) | 5.6% |
| Renovation and capital budget | $4.0M |
| Closing costs | $0.6M |
| Total cost | $40.6M |
| Stabilized NOI in year 3, after renovations and expense savings | $2.6M |
| Yield on cost ($2.6M ÷ $40.6M) | 6.4% |
| Market cap rate for comparable stabilized assets | 5.5% |
| Implied stabilized value ($2.6M ÷ 5.5%) | $47.3M |
Here the plan creates about $6.7M of value over total cost, a spread of roughly 90 basis points between yield on cost and the market cap rate. Whether that is enough depends on the risk of executing the plan, the debt, and the time it takes. The following entries take each line apart.
Sensitivities we always run
- Rent premiums 25% below plan, and renovations taking twice as long.
- Property taxes reassessed to the purchase price.
- Insurance costs rising faster than inflation.
- Exit cap rate 50–100 basis points above the going-in rate.
- Interest rates at refinancing 100–200 basis points above today’s.
- A recession year: occupancy down, bad debt up, concessions back.
If the investment fails in the bad cases, we either change the structure (less debt, a lower price, a phased plan) or we pass.
What sellers can do to help
The quality of underwriting depends on the quality of the information. A clean T-12, a current rent roll, a capex history, and a clear description of the existing debt let us underwrite quickly and with fewer assumptions. Uncertainty costs money, and a buyer who has to guess will usually guess conservatively. What to send a real estate buyer lists what helps most.
The entries in this chapter
- NOI and cap rates: the core valuation relationship.
- Yield on cost, basis and replacement cost: whether the plan creates value, and how safe the price is.
- Debt sizing: DSCR, debt yield and LTV: how lenders size loans and how we size risk.
- IRR versus equity multiple: two return measures, and why we publish both.
- Reading a T-12 and rent roll: the two documents every underwriting starts with.
This entry is general information as of November 2026, not investment, legal or tax advice, and not an offer of securities.