CaldrionReal EstateSearchSubmit an acquisition

Knowledge base

Debt sizing: DSCR, debt yield and loan-to-value

How commercial real estate lenders size loans, why the binding constraint changes with interest rates, and how we think about leverage as a long-term owner.

Debt magnifies the result of a real estate investment in both directions. Used carefully, it raises equity returns and allows capital to be spread across more assets. Used carelessly, it turns a temporary decline in value or income into a permanent loss. This entry explains how lenders size loans, how the binding constraint shifts with interest rates, and how we think about leverage.

The three sizing tests

Most commercial lenders size a loan as the lowest of three amounts.

Loan-to-value (LTV)

LTV = loan amount ÷ property value

Lenders cap loans at a share of appraised value: often around 55–65% for many commercial lenders, sometimes higher for agency multifamily loans. Loan-to-cost (LTC) is the equivalent for value-add and construction loans, measured against total cost.

Debt service coverage ratio (DSCR)

DSCR = NOI ÷ annual debt service

Debt service is the annual interest plus any principal amortization. Lenders often require minimums of around 1.20x–1.35x, higher for riskier property types.

Debt yield

Debt yield = NOI ÷ loan amount

Debt yield measures the lender’s income return if it had to take the property back, independent of interest rate or amortization. Many lenders look for debt yields of about 8–10% or more, varying by property type and cycle.

These ranges are typical market practice, not fixed rules; they vary by lender, asset and moment in the cycle.

A worked example

Illustrative arithmetic only. A property has NOI of $3.0M and is valued at $50M (a 6.0% cap rate). The lender requires the lowest of 65% LTV, 1.25x DSCR and a 9% debt yield. The loan is interest-only.

TestCalculationMaximum loan
65% LTV65% × $50M$32.5M
1.25x DSCR at 4.0% interest$3.0M ÷ 1.25 = $2.4M of debt service; ÷ 4.0%$60.0M
1.25x DSCR at 6.5% interest$2.4M ÷ 6.5%$36.9M
9% debt yield$3.0M ÷ 9%$33.3M

At 4.0% interest, LTV is the binding test and the loan is $32.5M. At 6.5%, LTV still binds in this example, but DSCR has moved much closer, and with amortization or a lower cap rate DSCR would bind. When rates rise, the coverage test often becomes the constraint, and loans shrink even if value does not. This is how many owners found themselves with refinancing gaps after 2022.

Fixed, floating and the costs of each

FeatureFixed-rateFloating-rate
Typical lendersAgencies, CMBS, life insurance companiesBanks, debt lenders for bridge loans, CRE CLOs
Typical useStabilized assets, long holdsValue-add, lease-up, transitional assets
PrepaymentYield maintenance, defeasance or step-down premiumsOften open after a short lockout
Rate riskFixed for the termBorne by borrower; usually hedged with a purchased rate cap
Risk at maturityRefinancing at the rates of the daySame, and often a shorter term

Floating-rate bridge loans with rate caps were common for value-add multifamily in 2020–2021. When rates rose, cap replacement costs and lower DSCRs put many owners under pressure. Fixed-rate debt with longer terms costs flexibility but removes that risk for the term.

Covenants and structure

Beyond the sizing tests, loan documents contain terms that matter as much as the rate:

  • Cash management. If DSCR or debt yield falls below a trigger, excess cash is swept to the lender.
  • Reserves. Lenders often require reserves for taxes, insurance, capital replacements and tenant improvements.
  • Recourse. Most commercial loans are non-recourse to the borrower’s principals except for “bad boy” carve-outs (fraud, voluntary bankruptcy, environmental issues), backed by a guarantor.
  • Extension conditions. Floating-rate loans often have extension options that require minimum DSCR or debt yield; an extension may not be available when it is most needed.
  • Assumption provisions. Whether and how a future buyer can assume the loan. See all-cash closings and assumable debt.

How leverage changes returns

Illustrative arithmetic only. A $50M property earns a 6% unlevered income yield. With no debt, equity earns 6%. With a $30M loan at 5%, interest is $1.5M, leaving $1.5M for $20M of equity: 7.5%. If the loan costs 7%, interest is $2.1M, leaving $0.9M: 4.5%. Debt that costs more than the property yields reduces current returns. This is negative leverage, and it was common in 2023–2024 when interest rates exceeded many cap rates.

How we think about leverage

We are never forced to refinance into a difficult market. Leverage, where we use it, is sized so that a downturn is an inconvenience rather than an existential event. In practice:

  • We test every investment with no debt first. If it does not work unlevered, debt will not save it.
  • We prefer long-term, fixed or hedged debt, with maturities that do not cluster.
  • We size debt against stressed income and higher rates, not against the pro forma.
  • All-cash ownership lets us place debt after closing on our own schedule, or not at all.

Read interest rate and refinancing risk for the risk side of the same subject.

Questions to ask about existing debt

  1. What are the balance, rate, amortization and maturity?
  2. What prepayment terms apply?
  3. Is the loan assumable, and on what conditions?
  4. Are any cash management or reserve triggers close?
  5. Who is the servicer, and is the loan with a special servicer?

This entry is general information as of November 2026, not investment, legal or tax advice, and not an offer of securities.