A closed Caldrion transaction. The property, the seller and our partners are not named. Figures are as underwritten at closing; yield on cost, IRR and multiple are targets, not realized results.
At a glance
| Units | 248 |
| Built | 1998 |
| Price | $44.0M ($177K per unit) |
| Going-in cap rate | 5.0% |
| Structure | Joint venture, 90/10 |
| Debt | Assumed agency loan |
The asset
Fourteen three-story garden buildings on 21 acres in Durham County, about ten minutes from Research Triangle Park. The mix is 96 one-beds, 128 two-beds and 24 three-beds, averaging 985 sq ft, and the property was 94% occupied.
The situation
A regional owner had self-managed the property since 2012 and never renovated interiors. In-place rents averaged $1,385, about 12% below renovated comparables at $1,575. The property carried a $29.5M Fannie Mae loan fixed at 3.85% through 2031, a cost of debt that buyers relying on new financing couldn’t match.
Why it fit
Class B workforce housing in a strong job center. Rents were below market and renovation premiums were proven nearby. The assumable loan turned the capital structure into an advantage.
Business plan
- Renovate 200 interiors at $11,500 per unit (quartz counters, LVP flooring, stainless appliances, lighting and fixtures) for a $165–185 monthly premium, about an 18% return on cost.
- Install smart-home packages in every unit and add package lockers. Refresh the clubhouse, pool and dog park ($1.15M in total).
- Introduce RUBS at about $55 per unit per month on renewal and move to revenue-management pricing, with a target of cutting the expense ratio from 47% to 42%.
Capital structure
$49.0M total: the $29.5M assumed loan plus $19.5M of equity (Caldrion $17.55M, operating partner $1.95M).
Underwriting at closing
- 6.1% stabilized yield on cost (year 3)
- 15.5% target net IRR
- 1.9x equity multiple
- Five-year hold, timed to the loan maturity
Key risk
Renovation premiums depend on the Triangle absorbing new supply. Renovations are phased and pause if achieved premiums fall below $140.
See all our transactions, what we pass on and our criteria.
This case study is provided for information only. It is not an offer of securities or investment advice, and past or targeted results do not indicate future results.