CaldrionReal EstateSearchSubmit an acquisition

TransactionMultifamily & residentialComplex situations

Mid-rise bought from a fund at end of life, Phoenix (Tempe)

A 164-unit mid-rise bought about 37% below replacement cost from a closed-end fund that had to liquidate near the bottom of Phoenix’s supply cycle.

A closed Caldrion transaction. The property, the seller and our partners are not named. Figures are as underwritten at closing; yield on cost, IRR and multiple are targets, not realized results.

At a glance

Units164
Built2014
Price$39.0M ($238K per unit)
Going-in cap rate5.4%
StructureAll-cash, with debt added at month 12

The asset

A four-story mid-rise with structured parking, near Tempe’s employment core and Valley Metro light rail, 92% occupied. Asking rents averaged $1,850, but six weeks free on new leases brought the effective rent to about $1,710.

The situation

The owner was a closed-end fund in its twelfth year after two extensions, and its advisory committee required liquidation by year-end. Phoenix’s 2023–25 supply wave had pushed concessions up and rents down, so the fund had to sell near the bottom of the cycle.

Why it fit

The price was about 37% below estimated replacement cost of roughly $380K per unit. With no fund clock, Caldrion can hold until new supply is absorbed.

Business plan

  • Burn off concessions as the pipeline thins, lifting effective rent to about $1,880 by year 3.
  • Introduce RUBS, reserved garage parking (80 spaces at $60 a month) and smart-home packages.
  • Complete light-plus upgrades on 100 units at $8,000 per unit for about a $100 premium.

Capital structure

$41.4M total. Closed all-cash, with a 50% LTV agency loan ($19.5M) placed at month 12, leaving $21.9M of permanent equity.

Underwriting at closing

  • 5.4% going-in cap rate
  • 6.7% stabilized yield on cost
  • 15.5% target net IRR
  • 2.0x equity multiple
  • Five-year hold, flexible to longer

Key risk

Concessions could last longer than expected. Underwriting keeps concessions flat through year 1, and the all-cash structure removes any refinancing pressure.

See all our transactions, what we pass on and our criteria.

This case study is provided for information only. It is not an offer of securities or investment advice, and past or targeted results do not indicate future results.

Insights

More to read.

Guide

What we pass on, and why

Ten kinds of deals we decline, each tied to a published criterion. Knowing them saves brokers and sellers time.

Caldrion Real Estate